Touring New England in search of autumn’s changing colors has become so popular it has sprouted its own subculture of “leaf-peepers.”
13.09.2023 - 19:31 / skift.com / Dennis Schaal
What impact would Airbnb’s diminishing New York City footprint have for hotels? One major hotel operator in the city believes the shortfall will contribute to a significant “tailwind” for hotels in 2024.
That forecast comes as Airbnb’s New York City listings for short-term stays — defined as fewer than 30 days — plummeted 77% from June 4 to September 10, which is nearly a week since stringent host registration rules went into effect, according to data that AirDNA provided to Skift.
And while Airbnb’s short-term rental listings fell to 4,600 from 22,500 three months earlier, listings for stays of 30 days or longer soared 48% to 34,900, and they now dominate the market, encompassing 87% of Airbnb’s total NYC listings, according to AirDNA. [See charts below.]
“We are bullish on New York and we view this as a tailwind,” said the C-suite official at a major NYC hotel operator, referring to the host registration requirements and new enforcement regime that kicked in September 5.
This top executive, who declined to be identified, is not an Airbnb hater. In fact, the hotelier tested selling hotel rooms from a half dozen of the company’s NYC properties through Airbnb, and one of them was generating about $100,000 in revenue per month, he said. [See more on these tests below.]
The hotelier pointed out that major hotel analytics firms were already forecasting about a 10% increase in revenue per available room for New York City hotels in 2024 versus pre-pandemic 2019. He thinks that growth could reasonably be 13% to 16% given the clampdown on Airbnb listings.
Not everyone in the hotel industry agrees. Some hoteliers argue that Airbnb’s inventory numbers are too low to have a big impact and that Airbnb merely handcuffs hotel pricing power during peak periods like holidays or major events.
The hotelier Skift spoke to cited other factors that would contribute to the 2024 tailwind, including a slowdown in the hotel development pipeline, hotel closures because of the pandemic, as well as properties being taken off the commercial market to house migrants.
Regarding the makeup of Airbnb’s current listings in the five boroughs, the first chart below depicts the sharp rise in Airbnb listings for long-term rentals, starting about a month before the registration rules kicked in, and the accompanying rapid drop in Airbnb listings for shorter stays.
This second chart displays the listing property types — entire apartments and homes used for long-term stays, entire homes and apartments set up for short-term stays, private rooms for long-term stays, private rooms for short-term stays, shared rooms for long-term stays, and shared rooms for short-term stays.
Two things should be pointed out about the current dominance of
Touring New England in search of autumn’s changing colors has become so popular it has sprouted its own subculture of “leaf-peepers.”
After a tumultuous month in New York City that led to thousands of Airbnb delistings, the short-term rental giant is focusing on Paris and other European cities.
Good morning from Skift. It’s Thursday, September 21. Here’s what you need to know about the business of travel today.
Earlier this year, Airbnb shook things up by rolling out 53 new features based on user feedback, including fee transparency and lower fees for monthly stays. Now, some four months later, the home-sharing platform is back with additional updates — and even more overhauls in the pipeline.
Editor’s Note: Monthly Ticket is a CNN Travel series that spotlights some of the most fascinating topics in the travel world. In September, we’re celebrating superlatives as we look at some of the world’s biggest, tallest and most expensive attractions and destinations.
Good morning from Skift. It’s Thursday, September 14. Here’s what you need to know about the business of travel today.
Artificial intelligence has been a major discussion in travel over the last year, and that’s why the theme of the Skift Global Forum is Connection in the Age of AI.
Looking for a short-term rental stay via Airbnb, Vrbo or Booking.com in New York City for the Thanksgiving holiday? One week after the city implemented tough host registration requirements, you can expect to see listings that violate the rules, more hotels, and stays in New Jersey.
Florence has been at the top of my travel bucket list for years, and this summer I finally crossed it off. It's since made its way to the top of another list of mine—my ranking of favorite cities. The food, the architecture, the rich history, and, of course, the gelato make it a city like no other. What I loved most about Florence was how surprisingly small it is—every restaurant, museum, and tourist attraction I hoped to visit was in walking distance of one another, which made seeing everything I possibly could see during my three-day stay doable. Hoping for an accommodation that was a little more homey and spacious than a hotel, my partner and I booked a gorgeous Airbnb with a private terrace in the heart of Florence.
The late Jimmy Buffett’s popular song “Margaritaville” was based on his time in Key West. Although Margaritaville was a fictional oasis (turned restaurant and resort) where people operated on island time, the Florida Keys is a real-life sanctuary where the sun sets in the west and it's always five o’clock. It's also a great place for a group trip. I hadn’t been on one of this magnitude since my high school marching band and I bombarded the staff at Kalahari. During the week-long vacation with 14 friends, I was most interested in going to the beach, enjoying the pool, and napping in the sun (lathered in sunscreen, of course) without a care in the world.
It will soon be harder to find a vacation rental in New York City.
September 5 was the first day of New York City’s short-term rental registration rules, but the city’s electronic verification system isn’t operational yet, Skift has learned from three sources familiar with the new process.