If you follow the short-term rental industry, you would have read or heard Sonder touting itself as “a leading next-generation hospitality company that is redefining the guest experience through technology and design” countless times.
25.08.2023 - 13:26 / skift.com / Srividya Kalyanaraman
There are stories of “software eating the world” and leaving a dust trail of fallen companies behind. This is not that story.
This is about a tech company and property manager that failed, and a leader who learned a hard lesson about skills and market demands.
Florida-based Black Swan, a real estate investment firm, has acquired former short-term rental operator Lyric, which specialized in multifamily buildings until its demise during the pandemic. The acquisition has bought Black Swan Lyric’s domestic and international trademark rights, operational and performance data, and the lyric.com domain.
Andrew Kitchell and Joe Fraiman founded Lyric in 2014 to demonstrate a use case for revenue management software company Wheelhouse, which they also co-founded. In 2019, Airbnb led a $160 million funding round in Lyric, which wound down operations during the pandemic when such companies as Lyric, Domio and Stay Alfred with master leases for multifamily buildings burnt too much cash and couldn’t scale operations. Sonder, which had raised $839 million before it went public, was one of the few of this ilk that survived.
“Hospitality is incredibly hard. You have to scale it patiently, and there was so much capital available,” said Andrew Kitchell, co-founder and CEO of Lyric and Wheelhouse. “I was a CEO of a brand given $160 million to scale. And I had never run an operations company or a hospitality company before.”
Kitchell explained he co-founded Lyric based on three core beliefs: One was that the short-term rental space was massive and misunderstood. Two was that professionalization was inevitable, and the third was that pricing and financial intelligence was incredibly important. If you wanted to actually build and scale a brand.
And at the time, Kitchell said, that the short-term rental short-term mentality grew out of investor excitement around WeWork — where commercial real estate could become a consumer-facing brand, including an upscale consumer brand revolving around underutilized apartment inventory.
By the first quarter of 2020, Lyric was operating nearly 600 units, mostly in multifamily buildings, across 17 markets. Notable Lyrics included 70 Pine in New York City, Park 12 in San Diego, Muze at Met in Miami, and Catalyst in Houston.
“When we went out to raise our Series B, we set out to raise $30 million and we ended up raising between equity and debt, $160 million,” Kitchell said. “And we were offered far more by investors, but we wanted to work with Airbnb and other folks. It was an insane capital environment. The notion then at the time was, ‘how quickly can you grow?’”
Kitchell noted that the cracks in a rapidly scaling operational business weren’t starting to show yet. “So we routinely asked,
If you follow the short-term rental industry, you would have read or heard Sonder touting itself as “a leading next-generation hospitality company that is redefining the guest experience through technology and design” countless times.
Blueground is seeing its apartments being rented out as safe havens from political upheavals.
Just about everyone has heard of Airbnb.
Software developer Victor Varlamov logs in every morning to work on a sunny Spanish island off the coast of Africa after the prospect of steep heating bills and a winter made harsher by the Ukraine war drove him to leave his adoptive home in Poland.
Due to an increase in demand in the short-term rental sector, Skift is back with our Skift Short-Term Rental Summit on June 7 in New York City. Building upon Skift’s comprehensive coverage of short-term rentals, this summit will focus on the forefront of the impact of technology, platforms, and professionalization on both the urban and traditional vacation rental category.
In the era of slow travel and quicker planning, those who wait until late might win.
There is now another subscription service for short-term rentals.
Portugal’s move to end its “Golden Visa” program and curtail new short-term rental licenses will not impact the vacation rental market in the country — not in the short-term anyway.
Skift, Inc., the most influential media company in global travel, and ShortTermRentalz, a division of the International Hospitality Media portfolio that provides the news and intelligence for the short term rental industry, are announcing a content and media partnership to share fresh ideas and insights at their respective events.
The Swiss city of Lucerne is the latest to place restrictions on short-term rentals. Lucerne citizens voted (64 percent) to limit short-term rental stays to a maximum of 90 days per year.
New York City is in the process of getting all the pieces in place to clamp down on illegal short-term rentals pending a July deadline when fines against both hosts and platforms like Airbnb, Vrbo and Booking.com for any non-compliance would begin.
Exactly a year ago Skift reported private equity chasing investments in short-term rentals and vacation rentals. At the time though, a short-term rental real estate investment trust (REIT) seemed distant.