Is the state of air travel improving? Not according to the DOT, which just released its Air Travel Consumer Report for 2015.
27.07.2023 - 18:45 / smartertravel.com / Tim Winship
In 2015, flyers filed 15,260 complaints with the Department of Transportation. That was a 34 percent increase over 2014’s 11,365 complaints.
The more damning statistic, however, is only visible in the longer view: 2015 was the worst year for traveler complaints since 2000, when flyers filed 20,564 gripes with the Department.
Helpfully, the DOT’s Air Travel Consumer Reports provide rankings of the airlines’ performance, based on the number of complaints received for every 100,000 passengers served. Here’s the list for 2015, from best to worst:
Alaska Airlines – 0.50 Southwest – 0.52 ExpressJet – 0.62 SkyWest – 0.65 Delta – 0.74 JetBlue – 0.86 Hawaiian – 1.06 Envoy – 1.45 Virgin America – 1.66 United – 2.85 American – 3.36 Frontier – 7.86 Spirit – 11.73RELATED: Alaska-Virgin America Merger Begets Sadness, Skepticism
It’s no surprise that Spirit and Frontier were the most complained-about, by far, or that Alaska and Southwest topped the list. Virgin America’s mid-pack ranking might raise some eyebrows, though, given that airline’s history of winning service-related awards. (It was ranked first on the recently published Airline Quality Rating report, for example.)
More surprising—and a mystery the airlines themselves would do well to unravel and address—is the disconnect between the complaints and the airlines’ quantifiable performance. Because even as flyers’ satisfaction tanked, the airlines were upping their game, registering improvements in delayed flights, mishandled bags, and denied boarding.
So why aren’t flyers happier?
My theory is that the complaints, while nominally triggered by service or operations lapses, are actually a reflection of travelers’ generalized dissatisfaction with the cramped seating, long lines, and consumer-unfriendly pricing and policies that pervade air travel today. So while airlines may be doing a better job of getting their customers from point A to point B and losing fewer bags, the seat-of-the-pants experience is more unpleasant and stressful than ever.
That’s a reliable recipe for unhappy customers. And unhappy customers complain.
Reader Reality Check
What’s behind the rising tide of air travelers’ dissatisfaction?
More from SmarterTravel: American Nixes No-Fee 24-Hour Reservations Hold Southwest Partners with Rideshare Service Alaska Air’s Bad Day – Highlights and LowlightsAfter 20 years working in the travel industry, and 15 years writing about it, Tim Winship knows a thing or two about travel. Follow him on Twitter @twinship.
We hand-pick everything we recommend and select items through testing and reviews. Some products are sent to us free of charge with no incentive to offer a favorable review. We offer our unbiased opinions and do not accept compensation to
Is the state of air travel improving? Not according to the DOT, which just released its Air Travel Consumer Report for 2015.
Beginning on June 1, Spirit will become the third airline to pull out of the Cuba market altogether, joining Frontier and Silver Airways. Two other airlines, American and JetBlue, have cut capacity on their Cuba flights, either by reducing frequency or downgrading to smaller planes.
When Muslim Advocates and the NAACP issue a joint letter accusing the U.S. airline industry of racism, it’s big news. And when the NAACP, the “nation’s oldest and largest nonpartisan civil rights organization,” follows that up with an advisory specifically questioning the racial policies of the nation’s largest airline, American, it’s nothing less than a media firestorm. Indeed, all the major news media covered the story exhaustively. And “American Airlines” has been a trending Twitter topic for several days.
Enter the American Airlines “Your Vacation Spot” sweepstakes by April 1, 2016, for a chance to win the grand prize: a $10,000 American Airlines Vacations travel voucher.
Alaska Airlines is justly lauded for its Mileage Plan loyalty program, which among other features boasts 17 airline partners, allowing program members to earn and redeem miles for flights throughout the world.
Tickets go on sale today from a brand-new airline.
Update, September 18: The FAA has issued updated guidance regarding usage of Samsung Galaxy 7 phones in flight, stating “passengers may not turn on or charge the devices when they carry them on board a plane. Passengers must also protect the devices from accidental activation, including disabling any features that may turn on the device, such as alarm clocks, and must not pack them in checked luggage.” The statement does not mention if any penalties are associated with failure to comply with this guidance. Read the full statement here.
Wi-Fi access isn’t free on Alaska Airlines flights. But at least for the next year, the airline’s passengers can use inflight Wi-Fi to send and receive unlimited texts for free.
Yesterday’s crash landing of Emirates flight EK521 in Dubai generated a flood of images of panicked travelers, loaded down with their carry-on bags, fleeing the burning B777-300. The headline of Bloomberg’s coverage of the incident said it all: “Crashing, Burning Planes Don’t Stop Passengers From Grabbing Their Luggage.”
On Friday evening—traditional timing for bad-news announcements that companies hope will go unnoticed by the public and unreported by the media—American published the new mileage-earning rates, effective from August 1, for travel on AAdvantage partner airlines.
I recently dubbed Alaska Airlines’ loyalty program, Mileage Plan, the “Best Mileage Program for Average Travelers.” It’s a hard-won honor, awarded for two principal reasons. First, Alaska has chosen to retain Mileage Plan’s distance-based earning scheme, even as most other airlines have adopted less generous spend-based earning. And second, Alaska has cobbled together a roster of earning and redemption partners that rivals those of the world’s largest airlines.
In just the past month, there have been two major airline service disruptions, inconveniencing hundreds of thousands of travelers.